Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nicolas Krause's avatar

I enjoyed this piece and I think there’s plenty of truth to it. For something with a broader view of an enabling technology you might like The Glass Bathyscaphe by Alan Macfarlane and Gerry Martin. I do think it can be overstated though. The Rockefeller foundation spent heavily on Edward Lawrence’s cyclotrons in the 30s but it was Irene and Frederic Curie who invented the technique of bombardment with alpha particles to generate new elements. Their experimental setup was almost absurdly primitive. The instrument builders were unable to perceive that insight. Finally Bret Victor’s Seeing Spaces lecture is I think inherently related to the ideas here.

Andrew Rodriguez's avatar

This piece was excellent and I’m very excited to read about your thesis in subsequent posts!

This question is out of scope, but I’m curious if and when the Rockefeller Foundation deviated from this approach of funding instruments (i.e. did this approach live and die with Weaver), and if they’ve had similar funding successes post 1950? Where did they go wrong, if not?

I’d also love to see you write about intuitions you have about underlying techniques that currently exist that need better tools to fully appreciate their outputs.

For example: “For the ultracentrifuge, cell homogenization, the ability to shred cell walls without damaging the organelles that were to be separated; appropriate suspension mediums, to prevent distortion of the organelles in solution; and centrifugation ramp rate protocols, to provide clean separation of organelles; all had to be tested and developed before biologists could even begin to use the ultracentrifuge to understand cellular components and structure.”

What is an equivalent of discovering how to shred cells walls, but not having an ultracentrifuge to understand the cellular components that exists today that you think is important to create?

Thanks for writing this :)

2 more comments...

Ready for more?